Premier League Humbled In Europe

It seems laughable that barely a week ago, I was bemoaning snotty EPL fans who looked down on football played beyond “the best league in the world”. Nearly half the division played in European competitions this week. The returns were, to put things politely, dismal. Let’s examine the games that have brought the Premier League the right to earn Farmers League status.

READ MORE: Elephants In The Room by Coach Ralph Ferrigno
SUBSCRIBE & FOLLOW: YouTube / X (Formerly Twitter) / Instagram / TikTok / Patreon / BlueSky

How They All Got On

Liverpool began the week’s action with a trip to Istanbul’s intimidating Galatasaray. The fans refer to it as “hell”! Despite Galatasaray finishing twentieth in the Champions League league phase, this was a match the Reds were expected to win. Yet, in a season of unpredictability, Liverpool again defied expectations — in the wrong way. Though Galatasaray’s defence looked shaky, Liverpool struggled to convert their chances after a promising start, wasting several clear opportunities.

Tottenham Hotspur’s heavy defeat, by contrast, was less surprising. Despite a surprising fourth-place finish in the league phase, Spurs — embroiled in a relegation battle domestically — were handed a daunting draw against perennial contenders Atletico Madrid. Tottenham conceded three goals in the first 17 minutes, prompting interim coach Igor Tudor to substitute hapless goalkeeper Antonin Kinsky. Atletico led 4-0 after just 22 minutes. Spurs rallied to score twice, but a 5-2 deficit leaves them with little hope for next week’s return leg in London.

Newcastle United were the sole Premier League side to leave the night with their reputation enhanced. At St James’ Park, they drew 1-1 with one of the tournament favourites, Barcelona. In truth, Newcastle were unfortunate not to win: leading 1-0 through a Harvey Barnes goal, they conceded a penalty in the 96th minute, which Lamine Yamal clinically dispatched. Having outplayed Barcelona for much of the match, Newcastle may rue their missed chances as they head to the Nou Camp for the return leg.

On Wednesday, the Premier League’s other three Champions League representatives took the stage. Arsenal, heavily favoured, travelled to Germany to face Bayer Leverkusen. However, the Gunners found the challenge far tougher than in their flawless league phase. Leverkusen struck early in the second half, only for Arsenal to salvage a draw with a late penalty. Arteta’s side, often criticised for their approach, continue to demonstrate resilience and an ability to grind out results — though their group stage dominance now feels a distant memory. Ultimately, Arsenal managed to escape without a loss — just!

Chelsea faced a daunting task away to reigning champions Paris Saint-Germain and their fearsome attack. Impressively, Chelsea held PSG to 2-2 for 75 minutes before a late surge, inspired by Khvicha Kvaratskhelia, saw the French side score three unanswered goals. Like Spurs, Chelsea now trail by three and face an uphill battle to overturn the deficit, especially given PSG’s devastating counter-attacking threat. The holders remain favourites to progress.

Manchester City entered the tournament as one of the favourites for the 2025-26 Champions League. Facing Real Madrid for a fifteenth time, City’s bright start quickly unravelled as the Uruguayan midfielder Federico Valverde netted a first-half hat-trick. Despite missing key stars like Mbappé and Bellingham, Real’s depth was evident throughout. City’s blushes were spared further only by Donnarumma’s penalty save from Vinicius Jr, limiting the damage to 3-0. It could have been so much worse.

After six Champions League matches, Premier League clubs had managed just two draws and suffered four defeats — a sobering statistic. The question now: could English sides redeem themselves in Europe’s second and third-tier competitions on Thursday?

Crystal Palace entered the third-tier UEFA Conference League campaign as potential winners, but reality has been far less flattering. A disappointing tenth-place finish in the league phase set the tone. Drawn against AEK Larnaca — who had already surprised them 1-0 earlier in the competition — Palace drew at home in a scoreless first leg. With two lacklustre outings against the Cypriots, Oliver Glasner’s men now face a decisive second leg, still searching for their first goal against stubborn opposition. Third time lucky, Oliver?

Nottingham Forest have endured a steep decline following their near-Champions League qualification in 2024-25. Now, like Spurs, they’re relegation battlers. In the Europa League group stage, Forest finished a disappointing thirteenth. Their European campaign continued inauspiciously with a 1-0 home defeat to Denmark’s FC Midtjylland. Goal scoring remains a persistent issue, and unless Forest — and Palace, for that matter — find attacking inspiration, both are in danger of an early exit despite technically still being alive in their respective ties.

Aston Villa finally gave English fans something to cheer about, becoming the only Premier League club to notch a win in Europe this week. Under the guidance of four-time Europa League winner Unai Emery, Villa edged past Lille 1-0 in France courtesy of an Ollie Watkins strike. With the tie delicately poised but advantage Villa, they look best placed among their Premier League peers to progress. The outlook for the remaining English sides, however, remains far more uncertain.

Arsenal and Liverpool, at least on paper, should have enough quality to reach the next round. But Liverpool’s inconsistency when favoured raises doubts. The mystique of Anfield’s famous European nights may be needed once again. However, Arne Slot’s side must find greater urgency from the start. That has been an issue for Arne and his charges.

Tottenham, Chelsea, and Manchester City all face daunting three-goal deficits. For Spurs, overcoming an experienced Diego Simeone-led Atletico Madrid appears nearly impossible. Chelsea, despite having beaten PSG in the World Club Final, now faces the challenge of containing Dembele and company on the counter.

Donnarumma’s crucial penalty save may yet prove pivotal in City’s hopes of a comeback — could this be their own ‘Barcelona moment’, reminiscent of Liverpool’s famous 2019 turnaround? There’s a sense that this tie still holds twists and turns. Real were comprehensively outplayed in an earlier game by Liverpool, with only Thibaud Courtois keeping the score down to 1-0. Los Blancos are not strong defensively. Meanwhile, Newcastle face a daunting trip to Barcelona, where the Catalans are overwhelming favourites to advance.

Aston Villa looks the safest bet among English clubs to progress in the Europa League. Nottingham Forest and Crystal Palace, though possessing quality on paper, have shown inconsistency — both ties remain finely balanced. Here’s a breakdown of each Premier League club’s prospects for the second legs:

1. Likely To Advance

Arsenal and Aston Villa. Both have the form and the score in their favour.

2. Should Advance

Liverpool. On talent alone, they should progress, but this season’s unpredictability leaves a question mark.

3. Toss-Up

Crystal Palace, Nottingham Forest, and Manchester City. Palace and Forest must find their attacking edge, while City’s three-goal deficit against a European giant seems daunting — though with Donnarumma in goal and Haaland up front, hope remains.

4. Facing Long Odds

Chelsea and Newcastle. Both clubs face strong opposition and uphill battles.

5. Slim Chances

Tottenham. A comeback against Simeone’s Atletico appears all but impossible, but after humbling Liverpool there may be renewed hope.

This week has delivered a reality check for the Premier League. The oft-cited claim that England’s top flight is the most competitive and physically demanding league is frequently used to explain struggles in European competition. While there is some merit to this argument, the EPL’s sheer financial muscle ensures that every club has a squad of talented players. Clubs like Arsenal and Manchester City, for example, can field two starting elevens capable of competing at the highest level.

At home, discussion swirls around whether the Premier League’s overall standard has slipped compared to past seasons. The league no longer features a single, dominant force. No current equivalent exists to the relentless Manchester City of the past or Jurgen Klopp’s Liverpool. Instead, the influx of wealth has spread quality across the division. Promoted teams hold their own, and established clubs face genuine challenges week in, week out. This depth and unpredictability, in my view, make for a richer and more exciting league. Greater parity!

Critics might point to this parity as a reason for English clubs’ difficulties in Europe, but I see it as a distinctive asset. The Premier League’s claim to being “the best in the world” is grounded not only in the pursuit of continental glory, but in weekly competition and high standards maintained from top to bottom. The Premier League is unique in this respect. True greatness is not just measured by trophies abroad. It’s also found in the drama, skill, and uncertainty that play out every weekend.